Silent Switch in LifeProof FRE and Catalyst Waterproof, which one is easier?

LifeProof FRE and Catalyst Waterproof are well-known for their military grade protection and waterproof function. Both have built-in screen protection and same drop protection level.

So what is the difference between those two brands, especially in their iPhone case apart from their overall design? The silent switch button!

With LifeProof case, you need to flick the button up and down with your finger. Some people uses their nails as it is sometimes hard to just use your finger. However, using your finger might affect the life of the case, as it might tear easily in long term.

While with Catalyst Waterproof case, the silent switch is a knob-like where you just need to turn it to switch your phone to silent on and off. This design makes it easier for user as you don't even need power to do that and it prolongs the case life since you don't need to use your finger like LifeProof case does.

So, which one would you choose?